« Where to Eat at the Olympics | Main | More from David Instone-Brewer on divorce »
October 22, 2007
Resurrection of Jesus: So What?
A large majority of Americans take Bible stories "literally."
A new study by The Barna Group shows that Americans "remain confident that some of the most amazing stories in the Bible can be taken at face value."
The nationwide survey asked adults their take on six well-known Bible stories (Creation, parting of the Red Sea, David killing Goliath, Daniel in the lion's den, Peter walking on water, the Resurrection of Jesus) whether the story was "literally true, meaning it happened exactly as described in the Bible" or whether they thought the story was "meant to illustrate a principle but is not to be taken literally."
The results are broken down by faith tradition, geography, race, and education. To take one overall finding, though: "The story of Jesus Christ rising from the dead, after being crucified and buried" was the story most widely embraced. Three out of four adults (75 percent) said they interpreted that narrative literally.
Yet polls and anecdotal evidence suggest that 75 percent of Americans are not living dedicated lives to the resurrected Jesus!
This should give us apologetic pause. A great deal of evangelical apologetics is about proving the historicity of the resurrection (or creation--intelligent design or 7-day--but nearly two-thirds of Americans already believe in a literal 7-day creation). The figures suggest that this is NOT the battle ground for most Americans. It is the relevance or meaning of the resurrection that seems to elude Americans. It is not a stretch for most people to believe that a God who created the universe could raise Jesus from the dead, among other miracles--Duh. What is a stretch is understanding what difference it makes.
Perhaps it's time for a new chapter in evangelical apologetics. Not "The Resurrection--Did it Happen?" but "The Resurrection--So What?"
Comments
Interesting statistics.
I live in the UK where I doubt the figures are so high - but nonetheless the number of people that believe in key parts of Jesus' life yet live their lives ignoring Him is high too.
There is certainly a place for showing the proofs of resurrection but I think you make a valid point. Also, it is unlikely any new facts are going to crop up to add much more weight to either side of the argument now.
"The resurrection, so what?" It's a pretty good question for practicing Christians too! Sometimes we get so caught up in our day to day lives we miss the impact it should have.
Posted By: David at free Christian resources | October 22, 2007 11:16 AM
Fantastic insights! Too much evangelical evangelism and apologetics is wasting its strength in the wrong fight. It brings to mind that whole debacle with Kirk Cameron vs. the atheist website-- the Christian argument was more coherent and slickly presented, but there was no demonstration of genuine love, concern, or compassion towards the atheist. In the context of the United States, our efforts should be placed more on inviting the "religious" to become truly devoted disciples than beating the atheist bogeymen with our arguments.
Posted By: Matt K | October 22, 2007 1:47 PM
I've been seeing these statistics and others like them for a while, but never really put it together like this. Great thoughts, but what are we to do then? How do we get the Word and Spirit of God into people's lives and motivate them to action?
Posted By: Etienne | October 22, 2007 2:06 PM
I am unsure how reliable the findings are since I'm detecting a subtle distinction between the nature of the two requested responses. The first seems a straightforward "what do you believe" while the second response is a bit more ambiguous in that it could possibly be understood as "how do you believe the text is intended to be interpreted", which is rather different. A minor distinction perhaps but enough to possibly skew the results some.
Posted By: Jim | October 22, 2007 7:10 PM
I would feel happier if it were the exact opposite: that many or most Christians are willing to have some flexibility in things like the Virgin Birth, the creation story, and the resurrection--seeing those events as metaphorical rather than literal, for example-- but understand the relevance and meaning of these concepts and how they apply to Christian life.
Posted By: Patrick | October 23, 2007 10:46 AM
The Holy Spirit living in us, Christians, is the one who will tell us when a passage or historical event in the Bible should be taken literally or not...it's an alarming thing that many Christians now are reading the Bible not by heart but by intellect...as if they feel like they're more intelligent than God. Instead of reading the Bible and be enlightened by the Word, they just criticize without getting the real meaning. It's sad how they're missing every part, all the revelations they can get from God. Satan is using our brains as tool for unbelief, but only our hearts and faith can know the truth, and that truth can only set us free.
Posted By: joanne | October 24, 2007 6:20 AM