February 22, 2008 3:45AM
Which religion will usher in an era of peace?

A scholar looks to secularization for the future of faith


Brad Greenberg

One scholar's answer makes that question seem like a trick. It can be found in the new issue of the Atlantic Monthly, which follows the November issue of The Economist and asks the question, "Which Religion Will Win?" Inside are articles on "The Contest for Africa," which Rob Moll discussed here, "America's Evangelical Future" and "The Coming Religious Peace."

The last piece is what really caught my attention. I wondered, How could this be? How could we be primed for religious peace after a history of warfare, from David collecting the foreskins of 200 slain Philistines to the 500-year-long and mostly bloody war between Catholics and Protestants to the hatred between Sunnis and Shiites (and Kurds for that matter) preventing Iraq from creating a cohesive society?

The answer, according to scholar and scribe Alan Wolfe, is simple: None.

Consider what is occurring within the growing American evangelical movement. It has built megachurches that meet the needs of time-pressed professionals by offering such things as day-care centers, self-help groups, and networking opportunities. Its music owes more to Janis Joplin than to Johann Sebastian Bach. Its church officials learn more from business-school case studies than from theological texts. And its young people - well, as the children of parents who have gone through a born-again experience, they are not likely to be as obedient as the evangelical leader James Dobson wants them to be. Having opted to grow on secular terms, American evangelicalism is becoming less hostile to liberal ideas such as tolerance and pluralism. New efforts to take it in directions sympathetic to environmentalism and social justice are a direct result of the maturing of the faith, which followed from earlier decisions to make the movement more appealing to large numbers of Americans, especially the young.

Does the pattern hold outside America? After all, it is often said that the promulgation of secular values and lifestyles, one result of globalization, is prompting a reactionary religious backlash. There is some truth to this argument, but it misses the bigger picture. Most of the religious revivals we are seeing throughout the world today complement, and ultimately reinforce, secular developments; they are more likely to encourage moderation than fanaticism.

Agree or disagree with the prediction, there is logic to Wolfe's argument, one he borrows from Marx and Freud and Weber.

Wolfe writes, "When God and Mammon collide, Mammon usually wins," which is a bit too broad but often rings true. Nowhere is there more Mammon for most than in the United States, and religion has responded to the many demands placed on our lives in the pursuit of Mammon by making participation more convenient and more entertaining.

But, at the same time, the churches that are hiring the MBA-carrying applicants, the churches that are growing, are also the churches less tolerant of the tenants of secularism. Whereas the churches that are more traditional, the churches that are dying, are on the liberal end of the Christian spectrum.

If you look at a graph produced by the magazine, based on data from Pew, it's incredibly clear that the United States is anomalous for the religious devotion of its denizens.

But does this mean American religion is destined for a "bubble burst," so to speak? I don't think so. The talk of the U.S. going the way of Europe -- of empty churches and godless worldviews -- is overblown. Especially when considering the fact that right now Mammon is becoming a lot harder to come by.

This article was cross-posted at
The God Blog.

Posted by Brad Greenberg on February 22, 2008 3:45AM

Comments

The Atlantic Monthly's chart of religiosity vs. wealth is very interesting, but it's based on only one set of data - the present. Without historical data showing trends, it's impossible to know whether the current state of affairs - a very religious but poor Global South, an agnostic but rich Europe - is a legitimate trend or merely accidental results of recent history. For example, one would be hard-pressed to argue that the Muslim Caliphate or the British Empire fit these trends - their highest levels of religiosity seem to have coincided with their highest levels of power and wealth.

Posted by: Mike Hickerson at February 22, 2008

Wolfe's prediction may have some logic to it, but it reveals a distorted view of American evangelicalism. When Wolfe says it has become less hostile to liberal ideas of tolerance and pluralism, he wrongly concludes that Evangelicals have been intolerant and cannot see the good in other world views. For instance, viewing homosexuality activity as sinful behavior is dubbed "intolerant" by people like Wolfe. He is unable, or unwilling, to see that Christians might have the ability to reject certain sinful behavior while at the same time deeply caring for the person. (That is a personal thing with my wife and me: we lost a wonderful son to aids because of his homosexual activity.)

"There are none so blind as those who will not see."

Charles J. Wisdom

Posted by: Charles at February 22, 2008

500-year mostly bloody war between Protestants and Catholics? Which planet? Probably each year since the Reformation there has been at least one P-C or C-P murder in the world, but to call it a 500-year stretch of war is patent exaggeration. And aren't wars always bloody?

As for the thrust of the Atlantic's article, well, bosch! (I only scanned it because it's a pretty windy article) This is just the same worn-out song that the view from the magazine's bubble is the most valid and determinative of all viewpoints. I can't make as confident of predictions, but I'd doubt that the Church and American Christians in particular will quiet down and cuddle up to the food trough. It seems like the opposite has been going on; thank God we're making more noise than we used to. Sure as God hates sin it WILL provoke a response though.

Posted by: Robert at February 22, 2008

No religion will ever usher in an era of peace!

On the other hand, it is in the characteristic of genuine faith based on firsthand and personal knowledge of the one and only God to usher in sustainable peace on earth. However, this promise has been made obscure and distant by Jewish, Christian and Moslem religions which are constantly at war with each other and even among themselves.

Peace is based on unity; and unity on common faith.


Posted by: Ephrem Hagos at February 23, 2008

Post a comment






Remember Me?

(1500 characters max; you may use HTML tags for style)

Verification (needed to reduce spam):