May 1, 2008 4:03PM
The ABCs of Journalism

How the ABC network botched a basic news piece on Wheaton College.


Sarah Pulliam

ABC's report of Wheaton College professor Kent Gramm's resignation was an example of sloppy journalism and weak analysis.

The original headline was simply false: "Professor Fired for Getting a Divorce." Gramm was not fired. He resigned because he declined to talk with the college about his divorce. (The image to the right is a screen shot of an earlier version)

abc3.JPG

Later today, ABC changed the headline to "Professor Loses Job Over Divorce." The headline is still not quite accurate. To lose your job generally indicates that someone took it away from you. However, Gramm voluntarily resigned. And according to the Chicago Tribune, the college offered him another year of employment while he searched for another job.

Also, student Emma Vanhoozer's name was misspelled. Most journalists are extremely careful about getting basic facts like these correct. But reporter Russell Goldman bypassed whatever fact-checking system ABC has set up, if they have one.

Not only are there factual errors, but Goldman imposes his own strange analysis on the situation.

"If the school is free to impose its beliefs on divorced family members where does the law draw the line? Could the school just as easily impose arranged marriages?" Goldman writes.

Yes, that's the big looming threat here: forcibly arranged marriages. Someone has been reading too much coverage of the raid on the polygamist sect's ranch in Texas.

Share this:  Add to facebook?  Add to Del.icio.us?  Add to digg?  Add to reddit?  Add to stumbleupond?   

Posted by Sarah Pulliam Bailey on May 1, 2008 4:03PM

Comments

I don't think that ABC is out to get Wheaton or is trying to be biased, but their misportrayal (and perhaps misunderstanding) of the situation depicts Wheaton—and Christian discipline—in a remarkably negative light. That's a handicap that Christians don't need in trying to show love and truth coinciding.

Posted by: David at May 1, 2008

The ABC article angered me. I tried to comment on their website, but my anger hindered my ability to communicate so I deleted my comment instead of posting it. I'm glad to see the issue addressed here.

This professor resigned. Regardless of speculation, he either had no evidence to document a divorce on Biblical grounds, or he chose to resign his employment rather than present evidence to the powers-that-be at the college. Those appear to be the facts. Beyond that would be mere speculation.

Thanks for addressing the ridiculousness of forcibly arranged marriages! Absurd!

Vicky
Sunrise FL

Posted by: Vicky at May 1, 2008

Great analysis. It's a shame that the media isn't able to cover a story like this accurately.

Posted by: Joe at May 1, 2008

The media in general have been having a tough time with this story. It's not that inherently difficult to remember the difference between firing, resigning and being asked to resign, and Wheaton's administrators have been fairly available to reporters, so some of the reporting that confuses the terms or fails to get comment from the school administrators seems just sloppy.

Posted by: RM at May 2, 2008

This "news" is illustrative of a disintegrating profession. Journalism is a relatively young profession, with roots following the printing press, for the most part. Historically, there was a town crier who may have been the instrument of developments: "tidings". The journalist of the early 20th century to the 70s would have tried to be impartial, if possible, and to identify editorial content.
As it stands now, the unwary reader is served mostly filler. My response as a Christian is to be disappointed, but not angry. What can be expected from muckraking yellow-dog news groups???

Posted by: alwynbilly at May 2, 2008

This story has Liberal with a capital L written all over it. The ABC news agency is attempting to depict the college in a poor light... to be creative with its headline and salient facts in such a way that will try to show the college as narrow-mind with a constrictive view of divorce. It is blatantly pandering to those readers who would shake their heads at such an unloving, therefore unchristlike (by their standards) way to deal with Professor Gramm.

Posted by: Mrs. H at May 3, 2008

It is inevitable that newswriting, though esteemed for its objectivity, is almost always subjective. Journalists put checks and balances into their reporting to prevent subjectivity. It is a shame when widely respected news sources, such as ABC, provide obviously biased and, therefore, unethical reports. The response of anger and rebuttal to the slanted article ABC ran on Gramm's divorce is appropriate. As Christians, however, we should not return volley for volley. We can be upset, we can reclaim the truth, but dissing the entire network for one man's awful reporting pits Christian media against secular media, a totally inappropriate place to be. Christian media is very selective and has a very narrow field of vision. We definitely need networks like ABC to provide news, though we are all capable of bad reporting. This is an issue of one man's bad reporting and a network that did not check his reporting. It is not reason for snide remarks about the network's enitre fact-checking system. I am ashamed that Puliam would stupe so low as to pit herself against secular media in that way.

Posted by: Lauren at May 3, 2008

ABC, NBC, and CBS, and their cable affiliates an offshoots have long since ceased to be news organizations. They have evolved into political action committees with liberal agendas. Editorializing is not only displayed in the words you write, but also the words you don't write. If you think we need nothing but editorially filtered "news", then these networks are for you. But if you want truth, you need to search a bit firther and get all sides of any issue.

Posted by: Bill at May 5, 2008

Interesting news., brother

Posted by: maidlyrhilia at May 7, 2008

Good report by Ms. Pulliam. One fact seldom mentioned in this case is that Mr. Gramm is the one who filed for divorce, not Mrs. Gramm. Mr. Gramm is the teacher employed by Wheaton College.

Posted by: Discerning believer at May 16, 2008

Post a comment






Remember Me?

(1500 characters max; you may use HTML tags for style)

Verification (needed to reduce spam):