Drowning in the Fishbowl


I walked up to the red door with trepidation. Please God, don’t let anyone recognize me today.

We had just moved, and I needed desperately to meet God on his turf. I needed a church. At the same time, I dreaded the people in a church. Dreaded the moment someone would ask what my name was and what I did. Even worse, I dreaded the people who would approach and tell me who I was and what I did.

I was working for a national ministry at the time, in a semi-public position. My name and picture were on the front pages of their magazines, and my byline showed up regularly. It wasn’t much, but it was enough to make me recognizable to a certain subgroup of Christian women. Well-intentioned churchgoers would assume they knew more about me than they did. They’d ask me about my children (which I didn’t have). Look around for my husband (he worked weekends while going to school full time, and so he wasn’t with me). Make assumptions about my spiritual life, during a season when the holes in my faith resembled Swiss cheese.

I almost drowned in that fishbowl of full-time ministry. I watched every word I said, weighing details against what I thought people expected from my employer. I subdued my liberal commentary on the state of the world (too political) and my bubbly stories of newlywed bliss (surely these people expected me to speak out of experience). I didn’t talk about the places where God seemed disappointing (how could someone who wrote about God have issues with him?). I hid a lot, protecting myself in the name of protecting the ministry.

That was exhausting, and so after a few years I gave up and fled church all together for a “sabbatical.” But I missed communion, and music, and corporate worship. And so after our move across the city, I gathered my courage and ventured back toward community.

That first Sunday was refreshing. I met with God and slipped out the door before anyone met with me. But the second Sunday, the rector had barely finished saying “Go in peace” when a petite woman rushed up and hugged me. Hugged. Me. I had never seen her before.

“I was reading my magazine this week and there you were! I recognized you right away and I know all about you from your articles! I’m so excited!” Then she looked around, and I saw it coming. “Where are your kids? Is your husband here? Where do you usually go to church?”

I’m not alone in experiences like this, of course. Women in all sorts of ministry and leadership positions struggle against the expectations that come with visibility. These days I am surrounded by writers who put their names on book covers that promise answers for spiritual life, health, marriage, and more. They are approached by total strangers in grocery stores and airports and carpool lines. But almost all of them tell me the hardest place to be themselves is in the one place where they should be safest – church.

Most of us fight the temptation to fit ourselves into a mold that will show our jobs, our families, and our choices in the best light. We are programmed to not disappoint. But in the process I think many of us have lost our authenticity, and we encourage the misconception that those who work in ministry lead holy, blameless lives. We discourage others from getting involved, because they fear others will never understand their troubled marriages, their rebellious children, their own personal doubts and frustrations.

That morning in the new church I faced everything I dreaded, spelled out in one run-on sentence of enthusiasm. But I found myself smiling instead of sighing. Watching this woman’s genuine enthusiasm, however misguided, challenged me to meet her honesty with my own.

“Actually, I’ll let you in on a little secret….”

Why is transparency so hard? Why can’t we open ourselves up to our church community and core of Christian friends, and let them see behind the curtains? God doesn’t tell us that we have to be perfect to serve. He wants us to serve in all our messiness. And more than that, he wants us to worship the same way.

Share this:  Add to facebook?  Add to Del.icio.us?  Add to digg?  Add to reddit?  Add to stumbleupond?   

Beth Jusino is a literary agent with Alive Communications . For the two years she and her husband Eric lived in Arvada, Colorado, she worshipped and was made welcome at Christ the King Episcopal Church, a wonderful community-based congregation that never treated her like the Ministry Representative, but always like Beth, who came alone and liked to sit on the left side of the sanctuary and stayed for donuts after the service.

Posted by Caryn Rivadeneira on June 13, 2008

yojude.jpg
Your Just Desserts, a resource from our sister site, Christian Bible Studies.

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blog.christianitytoday.com/mt/mt-tb.cgi/1263



Comments

Beth,
I've never heard of you. You should be able to find a church where you just be.

Posted by: Greg Wiest on June 16, 2008

We perpetuate the myth of perfection and then expect people to treat us otherwise? Interesting. As speakers, writers and ministers we always want to put the best foot forward but we need to let people know we are on the journey of faith with them. We may be at a different place in the journey but we, like them, face difficulties and experience doubt, anger, fear and a whole list of other emotions. We must deal with these emotions and situations the same way they will -- using the Word and faith and what we've learned along the way. We're not professional Christians, we're experienced.

It helps if we have dealt with our issues and learned to balance life before we put ourselves out there for all to see and hear.

We can open ourselves up to our church community once we've taken off the masks and come to terms with our own identity and value. Being vulnerable and transparent is freeing and contagious once you get used to it. Keep it up. What do you have to lose but false perceptions?

Posted by: Angela C on June 17, 2008

It makes no difference, whether you’re a house hold name or not, every soul is precious in the sight of God. Now, how other people view that is another matter. However, everyone is entitled to be who God created and purposed them to be. No one is insignificant. Everyone has a job to do and a place to abide in Christ. Some just get there sooner than others usually after going through a challenging process of personal acceptance of God’s will for their own life.

We live in a society that promotes individuality, but most often the pressure is to conform to a fish bowl mentality where all the fish look and act identical and carefully swim in such a way as to not cause any waves or ripples. So its easy to see why individuals may find resistance to “just being “ as they “grow in grace”…II Peter 3:18.

Posted by: Sharon Johnson on June 17, 2008

"It helps if we have dealt with our issues and learned to balance life before we put ourselves out there for all to see and hear. "
Angela, I agree with you to a degree. I think leaders often become leaders because they've done this. However, the faith journey is not a linear one. We may deal with our issues and learn to balance life...and then, wham!, something really hard happens and threatens that (a death, a divorce, a move, depression, a rebellious child). No leader will make it from start to finish without struggling (David, anyone?) The long faith walk of a lifetime will have many twists and turns and will go uphill and down.
So what are we to do -- as leaders -- when our road of faith is in the pits? What are we to do when we struggle daily to just believe? To be joyful? To stay afloat?
Is there a place in the role of leader to struggle with those things? Will anyone allow it? And who can we trust to talk to about it when we do?
And throw in the added pressure of finances when your leadership role is your vocation. Can you really trust anyone with those core struggles when your job is on the line -- because it is inextricably tied to your faith?
So I'll ask it again: can a leader honestly be honest about faith struggles? Will the church support him or her through it and anticipate the leader's faith walk to crest a hill again...or will they leave the leader for dead, alone in the valley?

Posted by: Mia on June 17, 2008

I agree with you Mia. Life is not linear and major struggles will happen. I've been there struggling through major crises. And there will be more in the future. It's a part of life.

There are no guarantees about how a church will respond to a leader's faith struggles. It may depend upon our relationship with them and their spiritual maturity.

There are some leaders who give the impression that they have it all together and have arrived at super spirituality. There are others who are transparent about their struggles along the way. Which do you think will have the support of their church?

If we're struggling daily to "just believe" then we really do need to ask for support. We need to find someone we can be honest with and humbly ask for help. Maybe it should be another leader in whom we have built a trusting relationship. The body of Christ is interdependent which means we need one another. Or, it may have to be a counselor who doesn't even know us -- someone bound to confidentiality.

There are some Christian agencies who have people who will minister to spiritual leaders. Emerge Ministries in Ohio is one of those.

It is difficult to trust, especially when rejection, betrayal or disloyalty is part of the problem. Sometimes having no one forces us to go to God alone. We can pray and trust God.

No easy, pat answers but I Corinthians 10:13 is true --"but God is faithful..."

You may find "Leading with a Limp" by Dan Allendar interesting reading.

Posted by: Angela C on June 17, 2008

Thanks Beth, for this wonderful message. It really spoke into my heart. Whilst I am not in any way a high profile church member or high profile in my community I am currently doing a Network course at my church and as part of it needed to identify my spiritual gift/s. It came out that my gifts are those of encouragement and mercy - wonderful gifts to have but really scary when you feel that also need encouragement in your own Christian walk. Your message has shown me that God can use me just as I am and that in the process of encouraging others I in turn will find the encouragement I need.
Thanks so much for this article!

Posted by: Louise on June 18, 2008

Beth--
I too have nearly drowned in the fishbowl. I have several books (Move Over, Victoria--I Know the Real Secret and When He Doesn't Believe to name two) AND I write a weekly faith column in the local newspaper, which makes me a mini-celebrity in my community.
My ego loves being recognized, but I cringe every time someone approaches me in the market and asks, "Are you Nancy Kennedy?" and then goes on to gush and fawn.
Even though I write the truth, that sometimes I want to quit Jesus and sell vacuum cleaners door to door, people think of me more highly than they ought, and that terrifies me--I don't want to disappoint them.
People don't want to be disappointed by us, either. Sometimes at church I sit and pray to be invisible.
Thank you for this column. I know exactly how you feel.

Posted by: nancy kennedy on June 20, 2008

Beth,
There is so much truth in what you write, yet so much heartbreak. One area I struggle with as I dream of having my first book published and becoming a conference speaker is the area of recongnizability. I enjoy my go-to-the-store-in-sweats-and-messy-hair life, but I so desire to "Make it Real" to women around me. I know that I have an authentic message, a message that will debunk myths and lies, but at what cost to my family? So, I wait, and work, and pray, and take small time recognizability as learning ground.
Keep it Real- women need and want it today- we've become disenchanted with the appearance of having it all together!

Posted by: Kathy Hansen on June 21, 2008

I can relate to what you felt, many times we just need to go in and just " let them see behind the curtain" (yours). I had to do that, they received me with open harms.
They now are learning a side of me that is different than they expected.
Yvonne

Posted by: yvonne on June 27, 2008

I know what you are talking about. I have been there, maybe not on the scale you are talking about, but I have been there.

Its hard, but I have come to terms with the fact that this is the life that God has called me to. Its that simple, and it helps me accept it all.

Posted by: Brenda on July 4, 2008

wow. interesting. i get annoyed with 'secular' celebrities that complain about being noticed when it was their dream to be known. I question whether Christians were ever meant to be 'famous'. I too am recognized in my church and around town for having a teaching ministry. I find it confusing, especially since i am so candid in my teaching. however, i have never felt like i had to 'put up a good face' in public any more than anyone else. We all have struggles and pain in our lives. I find it kind of arrogant to think our church experience is different than anyone else's. everyone has days when they wish they were invisible, areas where they feel misunderstood. i don't think it's because you have been published that you feel defensive. it's our normal egos in need of Jesus.

Posted by: grace on July 4, 2008

Post a comment






Remember Me?

(1500 characters max; you may use HTML tags for style)