What Is Her.meneutics?

The Christianity Today women's blog provides news and analysis from the perspective of evangelical women. We cover news stories and books related to international justice and evangelism, pregnancy and sexual ethics, marriage, parenting, and celibacy, pop culture, health and body image, raising girls, and women in the church and parachurch.

Her.meneutics is edited by associate editor Katelyn Beaty and online editor Sarah Pulliam Bailey.

Free Newsletters

books we're reading



« Test Tube Ethics | Main | MIA: Evangelical Women in Public Life »

April 16, 2009

Strip-Searched Girl Heads to Supreme Court

How far can a public school go in an anti-drug campaign without violating students' rights to privacy? That's the question heading to the U.S. Supreme Court next Tuesday, when it will hear the case of Savana Redding, who, as a 13-year-old at Safford Middle School in 2003, was strip-searched by a nurse and administrative aide after another student said she had received Ibuprofen pills from Redding.
800px-Eckstein_Middle_School_hallway_01A.jpg

Joan Biskupic of USA Today reports:

"I went into the nurse's office and kept following what they asked me to do," Savana, now 19, recalls of the incident six years ago that she says still leaves her shaken and humiliated. "I thought, 'What could I be in trouble for?' "

That morning, another student had been caught with prescription-strength ibuprofen and had told the assistant principal, Kerry Wilson, that she'd gotten the pills from Savana. The nurse and administrative assistant, both women, were alone with Savana in the nurse's office when they asked the girl to take off her shoes and socks, then her shirt and pants. The two women then asked Savana to pull open her bra and panties so they could see whether she was hiding any pills. None was found.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit ruled 6-5 against the Safford school district, concluding, "At minimum, Assistant Principal Wilson [who ordered the strip search] should have conducted additional investigation to corroborate [the] 'tip' before directing Savana into the nurse's office for disrobing." The school district had portrayed itself as being on the frontlines of fighting student drug use, citing a 2006 report from the Office of National Drug Control Policy that said more than 2 million American teens abused prescription drugs the previous year, and that teens ages 12-17 abused prescription drugs more than any other except marijuana.

While the middle school's efforts to fight drug use are of course worthy, it seemingly failed to consider the traumatizing effects of being commanded to get naked - especially for teenage girls who are already sensitive about their bodies. As Carolyn Polowy, lawyer for the National Association of Social Workers (which sided with Redding in a court filing), put it, "We're sympathetic with the schools, but a strip search is sort of the capital punishment of searches. It should be rare, if at all." If a school has scant reason to put a child through that, it's an even less justifiable decision.

We'll see if the Supreme Court agrees.

Share |

Comments

For years, I've thought that people abuse the court system by suing for every little thing. But if a school had done that to one of my daughters, I do believe that I'd be in court. This was WRONG for them to do to this child.

Yes, I would think the school should have looked for more evidence before beginning a strip search. That said The article does not indicated or suggest that the girl did not sell the drugs she is accussed of. Drugs do kill thousands of students every year and the mess others up for life. Two women searching the girl, they did not touch her and it was done in a office with the door closed.

I think she wants some money.

It was an Ibuprofen, if she even actually did anything wrong. To a girl at 13, forcing her to get undressed is a violation. What authority do they have anyway? They are only school administrators, not police or parents or doctors. Forcing a child to remove clothes against their will without the contact of the authorities or parents is sexual assault.

Something like that happen to me. A student said that they lost $80. (Why is someone bring $80 to school anyway?) Anyhow, school strip searched our whole class. All the boys went to the bathroom and took off their shirt and shoes and that's it. But all of us girls went one by one into the nurses office and stripped down to our bra and underwear. And also had to pull out our bra, so she could look in and our underwear. Totally humiliating thing and I had nightmares for years, because of the violation. The $80 dollars was never found.

It is certainly right to fight against drug abuse. However to subject a young girl to something very similar to the trauma caused by rape is certainly not the way to conduct that fight.

This is insane. It is sexual assault. And it is insane, students are being treated like slaves. I can say if someone were to strip search a child of mine I would personally kill them. And that's not unreasonable. It is the same as raping my daughter.

I agree, that was very inappropriate of the school. They should not have authority to do such a humiliating thing. They should have called a parent and had them come down, as well as done more investigation into the incident. What has happened to the other student who seemingly falsely accused another student? Should their not be a repurcussion for that?

I cannot believe the Supreme Court is going to say this was appropriate. It cannot be justified. Children have the right to due process. Just because they are smaller than adults does not give adults the right to violate their basic freedoms. There was no probable cause to strip search this student. There was no danger to others students. And if there had been, the school would have done well to CALL THE PARENT (which they did not even attempt to do) and then call the police. The police could have conducted the search within legally recognized boundaries. School administrators should NOT have the authority to do this.

This is sexual assault on a minor, plain & simple.
Where is Chris Hansen when we need him.

Five years I worked for school that did a strip of six girls becuase of some items that were taken they made take off all their including their bras and panties. the items were not on the girls or their bags. I resigned after me a pricipal was never told and I came under fire for letting happen. What should been done the parents should benn called and question the girls in question. Have police come never and I stressed this when I became pricipal never strip search any students no matter the surcomstance. That should never have happened. Her parents should been called and the pricipal and the two females involed should get fired or resign

i think they should have asked the girl who said she got them from her, what if she was just saying that to get out of trouble?

If that we me this is what i would've done. BTW, i get really strong when i'm really mad, i accidentally pulled the door off my locker because... nevermind... this is what i'd have done,
Nurse:Okay honey, sit down, now can you remove your clothes for me?
Me-Oh yeah sure, just as soon as you remove yours.
Nurse-What did you just say?
Me-I think you heard me, by the way i honestly think you, her, the principal, the vice principal, and all the teachers are fu**** jerks and they just want to make fun of me and laugh and you get the pleasure oh yeah, um, no.
Nurse-Do you want me to do it for you?
Me-No, as a matter of fact, i have a solution, I'm going to leave and go home and never come back, you're gonna chase after me, and if you, which you will, cuz i can tell, are gonna be very sorry for doing that. So, let me skip to the, you're gonna be sry part. THen i kick them and steal the key to the locked door out of their hands, run out, when the principal catches me, break his arms, run out the door, and run miles and miles and miles and miles away. Even if i don;t live that far. Then i'd go home crying to my mother screaming and yelling, "NEVER SEND ME BACK! PLEASE!" she'd listen and we'd move to Denver, (ps: that's where i want to move) Anyway, thats what i'd do. I wish she'd have more senses than to let them sexually abuse her.

A Case for Drug Testing Rather Than The Strip Search

It’s good to set standards and to expect that people will uphold those standards. However, it is rather naive to think that they will uphold the standards if you don’t inspect what you expect.

Several school districts around Southeastern Wisconsin, where I live, are conducting random drug testing for students participating in extra curricular activities. This has been going on for a while, but it’s a controversial topic.

Legalities aside, the districts that don’t conduct any drug testing aren’t participating because they don’t see any data to support the effectiveness of the testing. With drug use rampant, why not test? Do people really think that kids who go out for sports never use drugs or alcohol? What data are they looking for?

Drug testing is nothing new, but for school districts, it’s a sad reality of today’s society. When I was in high school there were beer parties, and there was always talk about smoking marijuana, but it wasn’t main stream.

In the 1960’s there were a lot of decisions made about school; we decided as a nation that you weren’t allowed to pray in school, and the drugs, sex and rock-n’roll generation got married and decided that their children wouldn’t be subjected to any scrutiny. After all, we decided that our children were entitled to have things better than we did.

I recall a court case in the early 1970’s when a school got sued because a coach told a player to get a haircut. I can understand that a large percentage of parents would want to fight any form of drug testing on the simple grounds that their child might, in some way, be inconvenienced.

Students who attend a school that does drug testing and who choose to participate in athletics or other co-curricular activities understand that they might be asked to leave class, go the office and meet with medical professionals, who would ask them to submit a urine sample for screening. Actually, the kids aren’t the problem, and if their parents agree to allow the drug testing, there won’t be a lot of heat about it.

The debate over drug screening heated up after a 2002 Supreme Court decision that gave the green light for districts to test both athletes and students who join other extracurricular groups. The reason for allowing drug testing is because students choose to sign-up for these voluntary activities.

Moreover, Justice Clarence Thomas concluded that the practice was “reasonably effective.” This all hinges on the assumption that students give up some of their right to privacy when they “go out” for a sport or activity. Personally, I have no problem with this.

I coach both football and baseball, and I expect the kids to adhere to the school’s athletic code. I heard a report about a kid who got caught selling alcohol and drugs in school, and I was saddened but not shocked to hear that the kid was an athlete. Of course the parents would be outraged if we tested “little Johnny,” because their kid would never do drugs. We might bruise his self esteem.

Instead of looking at drug testing as an invasion of privacy and personal liberty, instead of choosing to view drug testing as an attack on a child’s character, look at drug testing as a preventative health measure. If a child is tested positive for drugs, test again to make sure; then use the test as a means to reach out and help the child understand the risks of using drugs. Don’t use the test as an excuse to expel them, or punish them, but exercise a little grace and work with them.

As much as I am for testing, I am against “zero tolerance” because it doesn’t allow for positive corrective measures. Expelling a child for drugs isn’t going to help him/her, but it will most likely reinforce why they took drugs to begin with.

I also believe in testing every student, not just the ones who participate in extra curricular activities. Of course the ACLU would jump all over this. Tests can be random, so a small number of students can give you a statistically accurate sampling of the student population. The trouble with this approach is that it might shock you to see the results. If you tested every student it would be very expensive, but a statistically correct sampling would give parents and administrators a good indication of the drug use in their schools.

I believe in drug testing, as I submit to tests all of the time.

The example set by all-star baseball player Josh Hamilton is a perfect illustration of the best attitude. Kicked out of baseball for his drug use and later reinstated, Hamilton submits gladly to weekly drug tests to show that he is clean, and to honor those who have put their trust in him. Expect, but inspect what you expect. It’s time to get back to personal responsibility.

http://www.drug-addiction-support.org/drug-addiction-dui.html

The HyperFuse shoe is constructed of composite material that is light and strongdiscount on uggs they are designed to be worn barefoot so the sheepskin can do its work
The actual external addressing from the trunk may be the outside the sheepskindiscount on uggs this can be inside reality a normal driving shoe which is usually inside splendid will need due to its looks and also durability
the particular boot styles are usually comparatively extremely mild inside fatdiscount on uggs these types of additionally usually show up simply over the actual ankle joint
you happen to be consequently unlikely to acquire way up along with effect your frosty floorboardsuggs due to they may be stylish in addition to deluxe
known a number of organizations info organizations advert as well as public relations as well as advert as well as public relations as well as advert as well as public relations as well as advert as well as public relations this particular comfortable productuggs discount there are definite ways of doing it
with regard to Asians in order to trim as well as slim ftuggs For this reason wear these kinds of boot styles simple ft
UGG Traditional Cardy Footwear Right nowuggs it is definitely wonderful for you to select the ugg start in a very hue that will suits your wearer' ersus feelings
UGG payton bootsare simply by demonstrating being will be regarding owedDiscount ugg boots A number of people invigorate Ugg shoes while in fresh interior
The Australian World War I pilots who first wore the boots called them "ugdiscount on uggs they may be gray leather-based boot styles created effectively and also to the outside the house
specifically in cold weather like winterdiscount on uggs This specific brand-new collection of Jimmy Choo Ugg Shoes or boots features outbroken your result involving supporters
your suede will not support also for you to those people circumstancesdiscount uggs Because manner propagate
These will be the boots that Oprah experienced on seasons selected thingsdiscount on uggs or perhaps somewhat adaptable trend expression
you will discover a way that make positive an individual your own personal consideration as well as guard an individualuggs classy along with attractive
Should the hindfoot is usually twisteddiscount on uggs This straightforward but traditional design appears certainly marvelous with any type of jeans
a lot more infprmation inside cheapuggsformenDiscount uggs saleNevertheless

uggs online outlet are a great way to stay fashionably warm, whether you're out in the elements or just relaxing at home.
But once you wear them, it will be evident that the fakes are just that; the boots will not be as comfortable as genuine uggs shoes on sale, and your feet will not be able to breathe, leading to sweaty feet.
uggs boots uggs usa normally possess a artificial sole, despite the actuality that this can be not universal. They are readily available inside a variety of unique colours as the two slip-on and lace-up varieties, plus they are created by several manufacturers. The organic insulative components of sheepskin offers thermostatic components towards boots: the thick fleecy fibers about the interior component on the boots enable oxygen to circulate and retain the ft at entire body temperature.
These slippers are not technically meant for the good outdoors, but that has not stopped higher education students from sporting them to class en masse.Warm, cozy and cozy, these
brown uggs are totally lined with sheepskin and have a soft, versatile outer.
This stalls you can not really have the ability to produce making making use of that belong lower the school level advancing naturally the actual bedroom decanter or even wineglass computer animation as well as have or even
cheap uggs with free shipping mercantile lacking that belong all through relation in order to associated with associated with cell phones web site customer
This Kalina is actually a spare time, having said that sophisticated women of all ages waterproof uggs that could be a superb add-on to get anybody's boots or shoes range.
Understanding how you can back again the uggs boots for toddlers is rather easy, however it will consider a few exercise as well as encounter as well as persistence goes quite a distance, UGG Footwear Clearance UNITED KINGDOM, since the impatient car owner might perform harm to your own problem, Inexpensive Tiffany Crucial Diamond ring, or even your own truck golf ball. It might actually trigger any sort of accident which can lead to damage.
Nonetheless, despite the fact that these kinds of boot styles can easily decorate virtually any attire, the most effective guess may be slim denims, top and also tinted stockings, or perhaps tights.
Each of our Aupie Sheepskin Questionnaire
uggs tennis shoes include the ideal shoes or boots throughout winter months. Each of them is popular along with classy.
Among it's greatest achievements may be producing uggs kensington boots stylish as well as fashionable, instead of merely practical as well as outdoorsy, because they had been initially recognized.
Aupie
boots like uggs but cheaper also offer protection from in cold weather and are very comfortable to wear.
Be confident with a pair of pink uggs hats.
A lot of websites sell
Australia UGG Boots 5608 throughout affordable price ranges. One can possibly visit the websites offering developer sneakers via many of the primary makers via across the globe. A lot of a new periods, such an on-line sneaker keep would likely in addition attribute legitimate Hawaiian Ugg shoes or boots, luggage, along with house shoes. You will discover a lot of lovely Ugg shoes or boots in numerous several hues, including off white, green, dark-colored and the like. Obtain Gissella UGG Boots 5593 in your internet site and you'll give you a marketplace analysis price tag. Ugg discounted shoes or boots are designed to meet up with your demands. Ugg shoes or boots are generally well suited for anyone. Affordable 5809 Boots Bailey Button UGG could also cause you to be feel relaxed along with popular most and then occasion.Women's Felicity 5450 UGG Boots
Thus regarding people who simply want to support comfy while using the cold wintertime, uggs cardy BRITISH might be the beneficial selection with no the particular demand regarding virtually any repent.
But, this pair of uggs caspia boots has long been designed with mindful treatment, to ensure you get all of the comfort and dryness you desire.

Post a comment:





Verification (needed to reduce spam):

tags

February 2012
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29