What Is Her.meneutics?

The Christianity Today women's blog provides news and analysis from the perspective of evangelical women. We cover news stories and books related to international justice and evangelism, pregnancy and sexual ethics, marriage, parenting, and celibacy, pop culture, health and body image, raising girls, and women in the church and parachurch.

Her.meneutics is edited by associate editor Katelyn Beaty and online editor Sarah Pulliam Bailey.

Free Newsletters

books we're reading



« Friday Night Lights' Shining Female Lead | Main | Rumblings About Women at Lausanne »

November 4, 2010

Girls in Sports No Longer 'Tomboys'

There are also no longer any 'woman astronauts,' according to my 10-year-old daughter.

Athletic competition builds character in our boys.
We do not need that kind of character in our girls.
~ Connecticut judge, 1971



Last month the Women's Sports Foundation held its annual Salute to Women in Sports at the Waldorf-Astoria in New York City. Mayor Michael Bloomberg attended, as did actor Holly Hunter and dozens of athletes, including figure skater Michelle Kwan, softball star Jennie Finch, and New York Jets kicker Nick Folk.

baseball.jpg

Founded by tennis legend Billie Jean King 31 years ago, the foundation seeks to "advance the lives of girls and women through sport and physical activity." It's well known that girls who play sports reap many off-the-field benefits, including better grades and higher self-esteem. “Eighty percent of the female executives at Fortune 500 companies identified themselves as former ‘tomboys’ and having played sports,” the foundation's website states.

When I was a girl, organized sports belonged to the boys. If a girl played, she was without question a tomboy. At my brothers’ baseball games, I sat in the grass, picked at the scabs on my knees, made dandelion chains, and ran into the woods to retrieve foul balls. Growing up in the suburbs of Chicago in the 1970s, I knew only one girl who played baseball. Katie was quiet and tough and came from a large Roman Catholic family. Like her bevy of siblings, she had straight brown hair, dark blue eyes, and a scattering of freckles over her nose. I could spot her coming down the sidewalk just by her swagger.

Sometimes during recess, the whole class would play kickball. I secretly coveted Katie’s approval and, sure enough, when I’d make a good play catch the red playground ball on the fly, for instance she’d turn and nod at me, her eyes narrowed. She was a pocket Clint Eastwood on the school grounds. People said Katie was a tomboy. The first time I heard the word was when a boy used it to insult her: “Tomboy. Weirdo.”

Meanwhile, across the country from our blacktop kickball game, members of Congress, led by the late Patsy T. Mink, were at work getting Title IX passed. In 1972, they succeeded. The law states that no one in the U.S. may be excluded from participation in any federally funded educational program or activity on the basis of sex. The Women’s Sports Foundation reports that since the enactment of Title IX, “Female high school athletic participation has increased by 904% and female collegiate athletic participation has increased by 456%.” In other words, Title IX, now officially the “Patsy T. Mink Equal Opportunity in Education Act,” worked.

astronaut.JPG

My 10-year-old daughter is on softball, basketball, and volleyball teams. At recess she plays soccer on the field with two boys when she’s not at reading club or playing make-believe games with her friends. She loves playing Mommy and sits quietly in her room, rocking her baby dolls to sleep. She’s grown up in churches with women clergy. Her heroes include Eleanor Roosevelt and soccer star Mia Hamm. When we watched the movie Avatar, her favorite character, hands-down, was Trudy the helicopter pilot. Whenever Trudy came on screen, she grabbed my arm and sat up straight. My daughter is neither a tomboy nor a “girlie girl.”

She also likes to draw. One of her works has been hanging in our kitchen the past few years. “I can’t wait to show you what I made in art class,” she said the day she brought it home. “It’s an astronaut.” My mind flashed on Neil Armstrong, head tilted, helmet in hand. She then presented me with her picture. Before me, on a black construction paper background, standing confidently on the surface of the moon, was a woman. She wore lipstick and a spacesuit with the requisite headset and globed helmet. Her suit was also embellished with a flower patch.

I wonder in what tangible ways the effects of Title IX have rippled through our culture. Names matter, labels matter, and that it did not occur to my daughter to describe her drawing as a “woman astronaut” shows me how much things have changed since I was a girl. I am thankful for all the “tomboys,” for Patsy Mink, and for all the men and women who continue to push the doors open wide for girls in our culture. Their efforts not only account for the growing presence of women’s sporting events on ESPN, but also contribute to a more equitable society in which women can use their God-given gifts whether running down the soccer field or exploring the galaxies.

Jennifer Grant is a journalist and freelance writer who has written for Her.meneutics about mid-life callings, multitasking, and Lady Gaga. Her book, Love You More: The Divine Surprise of Adopting My Daughter, will be published next summer.

Share |

Comments

I, too, am glad that this is changing. But there are still times when people use the girly-girl and tomboy descriptions, and sometimes hurt others. My 7 year old daughter was crushed when a friend informed her that she would only play with "girly-girls." The friend told her later, "Oops, I forgot that you're a tomboy and not a girly-girl." (My child forgave her, but I've noticed that they don't play together as much anymore.)

I'm trying to stress to her that I want her to do things that she enjoys, whether that's sports or art or music or exploring the galaxies. As a mom, I have to help open those doors and not re-enforce stereotypical, traditional gender roles about what is appropriate for girls/women to have interests in. Great article.

On our honeymoon in 1953, I learned my new wife was much better at shuffleboard than I was. She beat me again and again. That's not all at which she was better than I. It was a great pleasure to discover her great gifts over the next fifty three years. "Tom boy"? Hardly!

If this were the only achievement of 20th century America, I think it would be enough. The glory of God is man and woman fully alive.

Eric

Awesome. Now when will boys who like art and dance cease to be "sissies"?

Good point, Robyn. I'm worried that there is still a double standard: it's getting to be okay for girls to do traditionally "boy" things, but it's still not okay for boys to do traditionally "girl" things. Now how can we tear down the sexist idea that boys who like art/dance/etc. are "sissies"?

We could tell them about Gene Kelly and why he got into dancing: because it helped him get the girls. :D (Seriously, that was the reason!)

Agree with Gina. We could also tell them that being talented artistically (dancing, painting, etc.) is a gift from God.

I was raised in Iowa, where the girls' basketball state tournaments often outdrew the boys'. Girls participation was highly encouraged to the point that people moved in from other states so their girls could play sports. The only problem was the silly "girls rules" half-court that was required for basketball (though I think that has changed). The girls basketball players in my high school enjoyed the same star status as the male players, not only in the halls but in the community.

When I went to college, though, it was a different story. It was a Christian school in another midwestern state, and the male teams were given all the perks and equipment, while the girls team were relegated to "powder puff" status. I hope this has changed, but I'm cynical. I agree that boys need to be given the same freedom to pursue activities that are traditionally viewed as feminine (until those activities become a profession--remember when women were allowed to cook, but not to become chefs? When it was considered "sissy" to play in the band, but women weren't pro musicians unless they sang and are still rarely seen as conductors?)

My daughter has another term for herself. She's a "tom girl" - an athlete and a girlie-girl at the same time!

Until the women in today's Christian churches make more concerted efforts to achieve equality within their fellowships, the Christian schools and universities will continue to treat female athletic teams and their respective sports as second tier programs.

I started in the martial arts over 30 years ago, when I was just shy of 12. I was one of the few girls in the class. Thirty years later, when I go to a seminar, I still one of the few women black belts there. My sister, when she was 8, signed up for little league. It was a giant sensation because no girl had ever been in little league before. She did it for one season, just to make a point. It worked. The next season, there were two girls on the team. Now, it's the norm. Progress is definitely being made.

Post a comment:





Verification (needed to reduce spam):

tags

May 2012
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31