« Beards: A Hairy Topic in My Household | Main | The Top Her.meneutics Posts of 2011 »
December 22, 2011Sitting in the Dark, Waiting for Emmanuel
Instead of fixing people's pain, maybe the most Christian act of love is to sit beside them, and wait.
A few months ago, my friend Stephanie’s grandma was diagnosed with a brain tumor. In spite of brain surgery and chemotherapy, the tumor has grown, and her grandma is now on hospice. When I had coffee with Stephanie recently, I asked her when she’d seen her grandma last. She told me it had been a few weeks. She said it was too overwhelming to see her grandma suffering and not be able to intervene.
“I don’t know what to do, so I don’t do anything,” she said. “What do you think?”
I have not faced anything as serious as what Stephanie’s family is going through, but I’ve had similar questions about a family of Somali refugees I’ve been working with here in Portland. Sometimes I’m encouraged by how far they’ve come, and other times I’m discouraged by how far they still have to go. Sometimes I’m so overwhelmed, I avoid visiting the family because it’s too difficult to engage in a problem that I cannot solve completely.
And then I think about something my mom likes to say, that God made us human beings, not human doers. Life is about who we are being and who we are becoming, not so much about what we are able to accomplish.
The more I’ve worked with the refugee family, the more I’ve learned that not only do I need to be as an individual; I need to learn how to be with others—not to fix or change or cure them, but to be with them where they are.
So when Stephanie asked me what I thought she should do, I told her, “Your grandma doesn’t need you to cure her. She needs you to be with her. She needs you to walk through the valley of the shadow of death, holding her hand.”
I told myself the same thing about the Somali family. I cannot give them everything they need, but I can sit with them in their cold apartment. I can eat rice with them from a bowl on the floor. And at night when the children are huddled together on a stack of mattresses, I can rub their backs and sing to them until they fall asleep.
Last year my friend Karen Spears Zacharias wrote a book called Will Jesus Buy Me A Double-Wide? In it, she tells the story of a Marine who had completed his military career and then gave up everything he had to work with homeless people in North Carolina.
He and his friends were able to get a woman off the street and into her own apartment. But all the money she had went toward paying the rent; there was no money left over for her bills. One day she came to the Marine and told him she needed help paying for her electricity. “You have to help me,” she pleaded. “If I can’t pay the bill, they’ll come turn off the lights.”
Replete of personal resources, the Marine told her, “I can’t pay your bill, but I can promise you this. On the day they turn off your lights, I will come over and sit with you in the dark.”
The Book of Job tells the story of a man who had everything—a wife, children, money, real estate—and in one day, lost everything but his wife and his life. And his wife wasn’t that helpful. When she saw how much physical and emotional pain Job was in, she told him to curse God and die. Instead of cursing God, Job took his sorrows and sat alone in a garbage heap, scraping his boil-ridden skin with glass shards to try to dull the pain.
Three of Job’s friends came to visit him while he was trying to live through the pain of unspeakable losses. They came to him and sat with him in silence for a while. And then, unfortunately, they opened their mouths.
They accused Job of having hidden sins, reasoning he must be doing something wrong to have incurred God’s wrath. In the end, God chastised the friends for their advice. Their mistake was not in showing up when Job was hurting; it was in assuming they needed to correctly diagnose and fix their hurting friend.
The Book of Job is not only a lesson in how to relate to a God we sometimes cannot understand. It’s also a lesson in how to relate to someone who’s enduring life-threatening, heartbreaking pain. Rather than teaching us the “right” words to say or “right” ways to fix broken hearts, it teaches us that sometimes the best thing we can do for a hurting soul is to be present with them. And to keep silent.
This week, Stephanie went over to her grandma’s house. She lay next to her grandma in bed and held her hand. She got to tell her grandma how much she loved her. She got to say goodbye.
The next night, when Stephanie got word that her grandma had slipped into a coma, I went over and sat with her while she grieved the loss. And when she had run out of tears, I sat on her bed and read her Psalms until she fell asleep.
Sitting in the dark is not only the purest way we can love each other; it’s the way that God loved us. He sent Emmanuel, which means “God with us.” Emmanuel ventured into the darkness and was not afraid to eat with prostitutes or let unruly children sit in his lap or touch contagious lepers. He did not come at us or to us; he came to be with us.
And now we get to be with each other. We get to engage in others’ problems and pain. We get to keep them company in their darkness. We get to be, even when there’s nothing we can do but sit in the dark.
Sarah Thebarge lives and practices medicine in Portland, Oregon. She writes at My Tropic of Cancer and the Burnside Writers Collective, and has written for us about having breast cancer at age 27. She has also written for CT's This Is Our City project.

Comments
Sarah,
Thank you for the international perspective. You hit the nail on the head; suffering is communal in many parts of the world. I wish it were more readily so in these parts.
Blessings.
Suzanne
Posted By: Suzanne Whang | December 22, 2011 9:59 AM
Thank you for a beautiful post, Sarah, and for setting a beautiful example of just being with a suffering person.
I've noticed that suffering seems far, far worse when we're alone. Having even one person with me on my worse days of depression helps, even when I think I don't want anyone to see me like that.
Posted By: Laura Droege | December 22, 2011 11:36 AM
Great reminder in this post. This is even harder to do for men because we want to fix everything and avoid that which, or who, we can't.
Posted By: pete dayton | December 22, 2011 1:45 PM
So true, all of this. Earlier this year, a friend of mine had her engagement broken. Not something I could fix. But I sat with her.
Two months ago, my grandmother died. When I got the news, a friend of mine sat with me while I cried. And that was what I needed.
The Psalm doesn't say, "though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil, because you will rescue me." It's "I will fear no evil, because you are with me."
Posted By: Andrea | December 22, 2011 2:59 PM
Beautiful post, Sarah, and amen.
Posted By: Ben DeVries | December 22, 2011 10:35 PM
Sometimes ... often ... the most priceless gift we can give is simply our quiet presence. No platitudes, no attempts at humor, no laundry list of our own woes, or horror stories of similar problems we've heard about.
Just. Simply. Presence.
And yes, Jesus wept.
Posted By: Linda Stoll | December 23, 2011 9:21 AM
Sarah, this is one of the best descriptions of the Book of Job I've ever read:
The Book of Job is not only a lesson in how to relate to a God we sometimes cannot understand. It’s also a lesson in how to relate to someone who’s enduring life-threatening, heartbreaking pain. Rather than teaching us the “right” words to say or “right” ways to fix broken hearts, it teaches us that sometimes the best thing we can do for a hurting soul is to be present with them. And to keep silent.
Thank you,
Tim
Posted By: Tim | December 23, 2011 1:14 PM
P.S. I recently realized something about Job's friends (thanks to Nick McDonald's excellent blog piece here: http://theradicaljourney.com/2011/12/14/my-journey-two-extremes-when-explaining-evil/#comments).
They each wanted to sit in the judgment seat themselves, usurping God’s role as righteous judge, deciding for themselves where Job had failed and pronouncing their judgments over him. This is nothing less than a rejection of God, and he condemned them for it.
As you say, Sarah, it is better to stay silent: "Much dreaming and many words are meaningless. Therefore fear God." (Ecc. 5:7.)
Cheers,
Tim
Posted By: Tim | December 23, 2011 1:24 PM
All what you related is very true and needed ,not only to sit beside sick or dying people or those who lost a dear friend or family member through aging ,accidents or illness,but even more for those who lost dear family members or friends in violent clashes or revolutions.I was thinking yesterday that we had to make an effort to reach families of the martyrs and victims of the recent clashes in Cairo and just be there to console them.Please pray for us to do what is really needed.Merry Christmas and happy new year.
Posted By: Dr.Nagia Abdelmoghney Said | December 24, 2011 1:15 AM
thank you for this!
Posted By: sg | December 24, 2011 1:45 AM
Beautiful post. Gotta share this one! Merry Christmas.
Posted By: Jane Hinrichs | December 24, 2011 1:52 PM
Amen.
Posted By: LDReed | December 27, 2011 8:18 PM
This is wonderful, thank you!
Posted By: Julia | December 27, 2011 11:15 PM
This is wonderful and should be read by every person going into church work. A few years ago, I was working at a Christian seminary and had conversations with several of the students who were heading out to be pastors or deaconesses. It was the hardest thing for them to understand that when trouble arises, often the best thing is to just be with the person, cry with them, and mourn with them. They always wanted to spout off some theological reason on why suffering exists, and how prayer was a salve, and how they needed forgiveness, etc. "No," I kept saying, "Just hold their hands and cry with them." I hope it sunk in..
Posted By: SD | December 28, 2011 11:00 AM